Skip to main content

Welcome to The Matchstick Children

In recent years, there has been much interest in the adult themes pervading classic fairy tales, particularly those by the Brothers Grimm and Hans Christian Andersen. One particularly common theme is child abuse, in all its forms: physical, verbal, emotional, and sexual (although the latter is typically portrayed on a metaphorical level). It is easy to find academic papers and articles exploring these themes, and how they reconfigure the way we interpret the stories, as opposed to the more topical level in which we may have experienced them during childhood. In a paper called “The Impact of Fairy Tales: An Exploration of the Relationships of Parents and Children in Selected Fairy Tales” by Helga Benediktsdóttir (http://skemman.is/stream/get/1946/17819/41602/1/BAessay.Helga.Benediktsdottir.pdf), the author makes the following observations:

In H.C. Andersen’s tragic story “The Little Match Girl”. . . the young reader or listener of the story is faced with abandonment and devastation on a painfully realistic level. Andersen begins the tale by painting an incredibly bleak picture of a young girl, out in the cold and darkness. . . . The situation does not improve for the poor young girl. The reader finds out that she is afraid to go home to her abusive father since she has lost her shoe and has not been able to sell any matches that day, and huddled for warmth she lights the matches one after another. . . . This is a terrible reality to some and . . . . offers only the grim image of a young girl in bare feet, freezing to death on New Year’s Eve as people in the houses around her feast and celebrate with families and friends (Andersen). . . . Her visions of others enjoying the evening in a way she is unable to, only deepen the feeling of abandonment and hopelessness. . . . (p. 19-20)

 The story “The Little Match Girl” (if you’re not familiar with it, you can check out a summary here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Little_Match_Girl, or better yet, visit your local library and read the original source) has fascinated me for a number of years because of a number of atypical traits it possesses in comparison to other traditional fairy tales. It possesses a brutal starkness that is unusual for a traditional fairy tale, taking place in a brief moment in time in the single setting of a cold, dark doorstep. There is little in the way of magical elements, unless you count the visions evoked each time the girl lights one of her last matches, which I always took to be hallucinations. Finally, there is no justice for the parties wronged, which is usually present in such stories, even when there is no happy ending.

Something else fascinates me about “The Little Match Girl.” In many ways, I relate with it on a personal level. The little match girl is placed in a perilous position because she can’t return home to an abusive family environment. She unravels mentally and physically because of exposure to intolerable conditions, internal as well as external, culminating in her actual death. This is one of the fundamental stories of my own life. I didn’t die, but there were many times I thought I might, because of the pain I endured.

None of my acquaintances and few of my friends know my story. Even the few distant family members with whom I still casually communicate don’t know my story. Shame, embarrassment, guilt, and confusion all stand in the way, as I know it does for others in my position. It’s not typical to be estranged from your parents, siblings, and extended family. Sure, many people report “dysfunction” in their families and certainly no family is “perfect.” Many people even go through periods of emotional distance from family members or may purposefully set up psychological or geographical boundaries between themselves and family members for the sake of keeping the relationship on a manageable level. But I know very few people who have actually had no contact with their families over a decade or more. I can’t tell you how many times, when I have shared the simple fact of my estrangement, without going into details, a well-meaning but misguided listener has said, “Your family is still alive, so there’s always the possibility that you’ll eventually reconcile.” Sure, they’re still alive. Sure, anything’s possible. But the truth is that although my family is still present on the earth, my family is also gone, and they are probably never coming back.

Although I have spent the better part of my life pursuing all types of self-help and therapy to help me process my experiences and cope with life in the aftermath, I still find that there are moments when I am plunged into feelings of hopelessness and despair. The occurrence of holidays and other big events that typically bring family together can definitely be a trigger. But lesser situations can, too. Seeing a father and son running together on the greenway. A patient telling me about cooking a feast for her extended family. Attending a baby shower hosted by a loving mother. Most of the time, I’m able to smile and move on, despite the tightness around my heart. Every now and then, though, I’m brought to my knees and have to retreat physically and emotionally, sometimes taking days to recover from the blow.

What has helped me probably more than anything else has been the entry of a few caring individuals into my life, with whom I’ve felt comfortable enough to confide the full extent of my story, but, more importantly, who accept and understand the circumstances around my estrangement. They don’t waste my time speculating about how things could be different and what I could be doing to improve the situation. They get it. And their acceptance helps me find a sense of “normalcy” in a context that is anything but normal.

Recently, I’ve been thinking about other people in my situation, and how the opportunity to commiserate with others in similar situations in a setting that is supportive and non-judgmental can be supremely therapeutic. I began researching groups available to adult children who were estranged from their parents and other family members. To my shock and dismay, I found a slew of support groups and articles for the parents of children who are estranged, but practically nothing for the children themselves. It seems particularly egregious that the balance should be so far in this direction when, in my experience, so many children are estranged from parents because those parents were abusive in one way or another.

That’s why I’ve decided to start this group, which I’m calling The Matchstick Children, in honor of the unsung match girl. I want it to be a safe space where people can share their stories, express their emotions, and find communion with others who have had similar experiences. I want it to be a place where unlikely "orphans" can find nourishment when there is no longer a seat for them at the family table. The only parameters for membership are estrangement from one or more parents (by choice or by force) and the ability to be respectful of others’ thoughts and feelings. Unkindness will not be tolerated – most of us here have already had more than enough of that for one lifetime.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Pains of Ordinary Life

Two days ago, a friend and coworker dropped by my office for one of our daily chats.  I knew that his toddler son had been having trouble sleeping because of teething issues, and asked my friend whether he’d slept well the night before.  “Well,” he replied, “My wife’s parents are visiting right now.  My son and his grandfather love each other so much, and they played together all day.  By the time evening rolled around, my son was exhausted from having so much fun that he went right through the night without a peep.”  I smiled and congratulated my friend.  On the surface, it was a casual exchange of pleasantries.  Inside, however, I felt sad, jealous, and even a little angry. I’ve come to expect this as part of ordinary life: simple and transient moments that trigger complex, lingering emotions.  A friend, coworker, or even patient mentioning their parents evokes the vacuum in my life where parents should be.  A description of a parental...